We noticed that you're not using the latest version of Internet Explorer. You'll still be able to use our site, but it might not work or look the way it's supposed to. We recommend upgrading your browser.
Click on an icon below to download the latest version of Internet Explorer or another browser now.
If you're unable to download the latest version of Internet Explorer, please ensure you have compatibility view turned off.
How to disable compatibility view
Shipping & Handling:
Ratings & Reviews
(average rating based on 31 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 31 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
( 1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
I bought these a while back(in a pack of three). I dont understand why sometimes these pencil just glides on and a lot of times, they tug and won't even go on my eyelid, I draw and draw and nothing comes out and makes me so frustrated!! I wonder if it's like the customers said about the eyeliner dries out. Whatever the reason is, these are not great eyeliners like they say.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful?
Yes / No
- You may also
flag this review
Hate this eyeliner
from Tsawwassen, BC
I have loved IT Cosmetics for years and I thought I would try the eyeliner. My eyes swelled and watered. It was so uncomfortable to wear and did not really do anything for me. I have had better luck with cheaper eyeliners. I would not recommend this to anyone at all!!!!!
By Grandma Sandee
from London, Ontario
I was so looking forward to these eyeliner pencils but I am not happy with them They seem a bit dry and cause my eyes to water.
I purchased the black/navy duo and quite like the way the liner goes on. Have had no issues as mentioned in other reviewsWould buy again.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
( 3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
from St. Catharines
I have purchased a number of items at the last show a couple of weeks ago. Normally I only wear natural products, but I was assured that the product is non-allergenic. The creator stated that she herself struggeled with allergies, and created this product. Having said that, as soon as I applied the No Tug waterproof gel eyeliner, my eyes and sinuses had a terrible reaction. And given that the product is water proof, it stayed for hours. I have never had a reaction before. I'd love to return the product, but it's not worth it, as by the time the shipping cost is deducted, I get no money back. I'd like to warn people, it is not a non-allergenic product.
Very new to the eyeliner world and..
from Kingston, Ontario
I use this everyday with the plum eye shadow. I have never been able to get eyeliner to look right on me and it usually pulls so bad its not worth it. I use the plum liner on my top lid and LOVE it!!!! I use the copper when I wear my brown eye shadow. Very easy to apply, no tugging at all and stays on all day until I take it off!!!! Thank you Jamie for this!
Dried out fast
Bought these eyeliner as it was recommended by my sister.I was not impressed as they dried up really fast. One I did not even use. Worked the first few times, then nothing. I tried sharpening them and still nothing. It actually tugged at my eye lids. Just bought the new ones that rolled up. Hope they work better, as I do love alot of the It Cosmetics line.
Made my eyes water!
I've never had a liner make my eyes water...but this one did. Sent them back. Otherwise I'm a big IT cosmetics fan. Just not a fan of the eye liner.
( 2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
While I like how easy it glides on, it is way too thick.
By star 64
I love the gel eyeliner , no more stretching the lid to get it to go where I want to. its does not stay on all day, but that ok.I have had them for 3 weeks or more, I have not had any problem with the eyeliner drying out, I do cap tightly and I have left them in the box they came it. I definitely will be buying more.