Shipping & Handling:
Ratings & Reviews
(average rating based on 19 reviews)
Reviewed by 19 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
( 1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
from Saskatoon (Saskatchewan)
I love Carol's ideas and designs. But I have ordered a few things from her line and some of it is hit and miss. I ordered these earrings in black and green. The black was missing some of the small stones and the green earrings had the large stone off center. Carol, please get your manufacturing / quality control fixed. You have a great line - but poor quality at times.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful?
Yes / No
- You may also
flag this review
( 1 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
from Sherwood Park, Alberta
Style was great however craftsmanship was poor. The tear shaped spinel did not fit the backing so you could see the backing. This made them look very cheap and of course they were not. I have had many pieces from Carol Brodie and they have been great.
C Brodie Earings.
I loved the earrings but the color was a little different than what I expected.
Disappointed with quality
Looked great on television. Not so in person. Returned the green onyx pair, as accent stones were missing from both earrings. Made it an easy decision to return something of such questionable quality. Highly overpriced.
( 2 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
First time I have ordered Carol Brodie. The quality is poor. Will not order again.
WHAT AN INCREDIBLE DISAPPOINTMENT
By Tamara Anne, Shopaholic
from Markham, Ontario
The earrings looked fabulous during the show...but that's where it ended. What a disappointment. They looked classy, but they were so cheaply manufactured they felt like substandard costume jewellery.I returned them without hesitation.
( 2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
I received my pair very quickly; however, I was disappointed to have to return my spinels as there was a stone missing from around the perimeter
( 7 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
Great design but cheap, cheap quality
from VICTORIA, BC
I so want to keep these earrings!!! I love the size, shape and design. My labradorite pair weren't defective but the quality is so poor - cheap street vendor quality. In light of other feedback, I suspect they won't hold up so I'm returning them. Carol seems genuinely interested in cultivating a Canadian following and kudos to her for her preparation for the SS presentation, but her production team is letting her down. She really needs to focus on quality control before she irreparably damages her reputation. In light of previous disappointing experiences with Carol's line and the change in shipping/return policy, it is highly unlikely I will gamble on ordering from this line again.
( 12 of 14 customers found this review helpful)
Seeing is not always believing. These looked lovely, substantial and seemingly well made on T.V. but I cannot get these packed up and shipped off quickly enough. The idea is a good one but the workmanship and quality is LACKING.Will be checking the NEW returns policy as suggested by Pepper and that cerainly will influence future purchases of any kind. Carol's ideas are truly wonderful but whoever is putting this together for her has failed her and secondly she is losing future customers and that is truly sad as we need to do the best for each other.
( 7 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
By tsc regular shopper
I purchased the labradorite earrings choice to give my daughter for her birthday in Jan. but had the same thing happen as to reviewer Reina from BC when I tried them on in my ears. The leverback on one broke right off as well while the other worked properly and snapped closed tight without a problem. It was bent already when removed from the little plastic bag and snapped off during closing while the other one opened easily and closed easily and lined up properly with the back.Too bad both leverbacks didn't match and work so I am returning these as my daughter wouldn't want problems with the closure fearing loss. All stones were there and the labradorites were beautiful in colour but I'm not impressed with the quality for even the showstopper price. Glad I got to try them out first before giving as a gift - that's for sure!