We noticed that you're not using the latest version of Internet Explorer. You'll still be able to use our site, but it might not work or look the way it's supposed to. We recommend upgrading your browser.
Click on an icon below to download the latest version of Internet Explorer or another browser now.
If you're unable to download the latest version of Internet Explorer, please ensure you have compatibility view turned off.
How to disable compatibility view
Shipping & Handling:
Ratings & Reviews
(average rating based on 22 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 22 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
( 5 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
I ordered several items from Carols' line with mixed conclusions, some were great others had to be exchanged, some even few times... Anyhow, when I ordered these earrings (labradorite version) I expected the item to arrive damaged, broken, etc based on all the other reviews. The earrings arrived in perfect condition and they are absolutely beautiful! They are my favorite earrings at the moment and I am considering ordering another pair with different stone. Overall, even though there was nothing wrong with these earrings I do agree with other buyers/consumers that the manufacturing quality of Carols' jewellery is short of perfect, considering the pricing of those pieces as well as the caliber of the designer! I do like her designs and stone combinations I wish that the quality improve so I would not have to be disappointed in the future. I would recommend this line to a friend with a word of caution.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful?
Yes / No
- You may also
flag this review
( 9 of 9 customers found this review helpful)
Pretty but poor quality
I was really excited to get these earrings especially at the reduced price. When they arrive home, there were several stones missing from each earring and I was very disappointed. So I am returning them. They are also a little weighty for those ladies that do not like a heavy earring. Something to consider for future.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
( 11 of 11 customers found this review helpful)
By Melc the Fashionesta
from Sudbury, ON
They looked absolutely gorgeous on TV but not so much in person. I agree with everything everyone else said. I am so angry I did not check the earrings right away. I just took a quick look and wrapped them as a present for my girlfriend. My husband and I were both shocked when she tried them on and they broke right in her hand. Her husband made a joke out of it but I was really disappointed and too late to return them. I did show her my receipt so she could see I was not giving her cheap earrings and she was amazed that they were so cheaply made.
from Saskatoon (Saskatchewan)
I love Carol's ideas and designs. But I have ordered a few things from her line and some of it is hit and miss. I ordered these earrings in black and green. The black was missing some of the small stones and the green earrings had the large stone off center. Carol, please get your manufacturing / quality control fixed. You have a great line - but poor quality at times.
( 5 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
C Brodie Earings.
I loved the earrings but the color was a little different than what I expected.
( 7 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
from Sherwood Park, Alberta
Style was great however craftsmanship was poor. The tear shaped spinel did not fit the backing so you could see the backing. This made them look very cheap and of course they were not. I have had many pieces from Carol Brodie and they have been great.
( 8 of 9 customers found this review helpful)
Disappointed with quality
Looked great on television. Not so in person. Returned the green onyx pair, as accent stones were missing from both earrings. Made it an easy decision to return something of such questionable quality. Highly overpriced.
( 9 of 10 customers found this review helpful)
First time I have ordered Carol Brodie. The quality is poor. Will not order again.
WHAT AN INCREDIBLE DISAPPOINTMENT
By Tamara Anne, Shopaholic
from Markham, Ontario
The earrings looked fabulous during the show...but that's where it ended. What a disappointment. They looked classy, but they were so cheaply manufactured they felt like substandard costume jewellery.I returned them without hesitation.
( 7 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
I received my pair very quickly; however, I was disappointed to have to return my spinels as there was a stone missing from around the perimeter