Shipping & Handling: $9.98
Ratings & Reviews
(average rating based on 40 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 40 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Not the Best
from Toronto, Ontario
I agree the ring is somewhat disappointing; the band was slightly tarnished but came off easily without damaging the rose gold plating. However, the morganite and diamonds are lovely and sparkly nicely.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful?
Yes / No
- You may also
flag this review
I love this ring!!!!
By Passion Bling
from Rockwood, Ontario
I purchased the Yellow Emerald ring and I just love it. I have had many compliments, in fact every time I wear it. I take my jewellery off when cleaning or dishes. I agree the diamonds could have been of better quality. The yellow gold has not changed as yet. I do enjoy my ring.
( 8 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
By Janet the Happy Shopper
I purchased this in the Morganite. I was really exited to receive it, however when I did I was totally disappointed. The ring itself seemed a little flimsy - band was really narrow. The color (rosegold) was tarnished very badly like a copper penny around the prongs and band. After hearing Carol speak about this ring and the apraisals she received, I was totally psyched. Received it one day and returned it the next. The packaging wasn't anything great either. Don't think I'll order anything from her collection again.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
( 4 of 4 customers found this review helpful)
By I love the shopping channel!!
I was so excited to receive my purchase, but when I opened the rose sterling morganite ring, I gasped when I noticed it was tarnished, which led me to believe that the other two rings I purchased would eventually tarnish. I sent all 3 rings back. very disappointed. I don't know if I will purchase Carol Brodie products again.
( 7 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
Morganite Halo Ring Very Poor Quality
By cat the perrfect
from Winnipeg, Mb
Carol Brodie, the pink gold plating on this Morganite ring is such poor quality I don't understand how you could have spoken so highly about it as your showstopper. I received the ring in a cheap black cardboard box, and it was so badly tarnished, that it was the color of black on the ring shank. When I took a polishing cloth to it, not only did it rub off the black tarnish, but the pink gold plating came off with it too! Really bad! I would not recommend this to anybody, who is thinking of purchasing it.
( 2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
By L. from Milton
from Milton, ON
How disappointing! The setting is beautiful, the acquamarine almost colourless and the diamonds are very cloudy with hardly any sparkle. The only sparkle comes from the silver and top of diamonds when held at an angle. Carol should have used either white sapphires or white zircons (not cubic zirconia) both those gemstones sparkle more than the diamonds used in this ring. I would have kept the ring if the diamonds were better quality or had they been sapphires or zircons. Carol Brodie should have better quality control on her jewellery. I purchased a couple of other rings by Carol Brodie and the main gemstones were surrounded by zircons and I was sooooo impressed with them.
very disappointed in carol brodie
from vancouver, b.c
very poor quality of the rose sterling, came out of box and was tarnished. Morganite very nice with the diamonds and not white topaz. You would think that since this was a showstopper much better quality and care should have gone into product before so many people bought. Looks like people are sending back, so what was the point.
( 10 of 10 customers found this review helpful)
I would not recommand to buy it
I purchased yellow emerald from show stopper. It didn't take long for product to arrive. The setting looks beautiful, but the band is very thin. Gold plated is not in good quality, my ring is alreday turning brown with tarnish spots and looks so terrible. I thought of returning it, but unfortunately I already discards the package.I normally kept it in its box, and today brought it out...it looks like a toy ring from dollar store.In conclusion...very disappointed..I would not recommand any one to buy it. It is too over price for such low quality.
( 11 of 11 customers found this review helpful)
Less Than A One Star Rating!
from Medicine Hat, Alberta
What a piece of garbage! The morganite ring is not only missing a diamond, but the ENTIRE inside of this extremely thin band in now completely black and the outside is silver. Wondering what this ring is really made of. I'd like to get the morganite and diamonds checked too, as I'm sure they're not real, as other customers have confirmed in the past with other items. This line should be banned from TSC unless it doesn't mind losing its reputation!
( 5 of 5 customers found this review helpful)
Very disappointing and poor quality...
from Vancouver, BC
Just like the other shoppers,I agree.The rose gold plating turned black within 2 days.This is the second ring I have sent back from this collection and for the same reasons. I gave it a star for the morganite gemstone.